What Does the Approval Hell in Hong Kong Media Look Like?

Have you ever seen a Hong Kong newsroom at 3 a.m.? It's not bustling with activity to meet deadlines, but rather five people frantically messaging in a WhatsApp group: "Has anyone seen the editor-in-chief? Can we publish this article or not?" One person is catching up on sleep across the Tokyo time zone, legal staff are on vacation in mainland China with spotty signal, and the reporter’s eighth revised Word document is buried under dozens of voice messages. In the end, they publish a draft from three days ago. This kind of “approval hell” is simply business as usual in Hong Kong media—multi-layered approvals resemble a video game where every boss is offline.

Even more absurd is that local news often turns into a cross-time-zone disaster due to fragmented collaboration tools. Email exchanges move in slow motion, attachments pile up endlessly, and no one knows who changed which sentence. Accountability? Pure luck. Once, during a breaking news event, photos, copy, and legal advice were all ready—but publication stalled because no one could locate the one person needed to click “approve.” A rival outlet scooped them by two hours, leaving the editor so furious he nearly threw his laptop out the window.

Small and medium-sized media outlets are especially trapped in the “WhatsApp office” frog-in-boiling-water scenario—convenient, yes, but trying to trace decision-making paths feels like searching for a needle in a garbage dump. It’s less a workflow and more like a “whatever-happens-happens” flow. That was until someone realized technology could be used for more than just clocking in…



DingTalk Isn’t Just for Clocking In—It’s an Approval Command Center

Who says DingTalk is only good for clocking in, attending meetings, or being monitored by your boss? In Hong Kong newsrooms, it has evolved into an “approval command center,” burying the old divination-like approval process—“Hey, did you check it yet?” or “My inbox is flooded with thirty versions!”—into a digital graveyard. The essence of DingTalk workflows lies in transforming chaotic human rule into precise system governance: the moment a reporter submits a piece, a preset route automatically pushes it to editors, legal, and the editor-in-chief. Each step comes with countdown alerts; if delayed even a second, the system chases you down like a ghost, far more effective than any deadline threat.

Even better is version tracking—no more guessing who changed what in files named “final_final_reallyfinal.doc.” All editing records are instantly accessible, and attachments are embedded directly into the workflow, eliminating risks of missing images or legal notes. Most importantly, mobile processing allows real-time action: even if the editor-in-chief is mid-flight without Wi-Fi, they can approve the piece the moment they land. Consider this: an international feature article previously took an average of 4.7 hours via email back-and-forth; now, with DingTalk, it takes just 78 minutes. The saved communication costs could easily cover two rounds of iced lemon tea for the entire team. Structured workflows aren’t just faster—they’re clean, clear, and assign responsibility precisely. Made a mistake? One look at the log reveals exactly who hit the wrong button.



Local Adaptation: How Hong Kong Media Customize DingTalk

If DingTalk is the approval command center, Hong Kong media aren’t just accepting the default settings—they’re more like street mechanics tearing apart factory models, adding turbochargers and upgrading suspensions to dominate tight corners. One major newspaper’s newsroom jokes: “We don’t use regular workflows—we use ‘Hong Kong-style workflows’!”

For example, why should standard approval fields only include “comments”? Hong Kong reporters immediately demanded a dedicated “Cantonese colloquial notes” section, allowing frontline staff to communicate in local expressions like “check if this line might mislead the caption.” Legal colleagues no longer frown and ask, “What exactly are they saying here?” Some outlets have integrated local image libraries, enabling one-click access to licensed photos from Getty or freelance photographers, complete with usage expiry reminders to avoid the tragedy of “it was usable yesterday but today we get a lawyer’s letter.”

The most brilliant innovation is the “breaking news fast track”—when social unrest, typhoons, or stock market crashes hit, the system automatically bypasses three layers of routine review and sends a pop-up alert directly to the editor-in-chief’s phone. Two taps and it’s published—faster than making coffee. Integrated with existing CMS systems, it even auto-checks headline length, turning chaos into one-click simplicity and panic into peace of mind.



Transparent Approvals Mean Clearer Accountability

In newsrooms, nothing used to be scarier than hearing: “I thought you’d already fixed it!” Typos made it to print, unlicensed images ran in articles, and blame-shifting became routine—legal teams often trembling in fear. Since implementing DingTalk workflows, the approval process has shifted from a black box to full transparency. Every decision leaves a “digital footprint”: Reporter Zhang submitted at 10:23 p.m., Editor Li commented while walking, “headline too sensational,” and Editor-in-Chief Wang gave a midnight “OK, publish”—all automatically recorded, denial impossible. The system shows no mercy, but it’s precisely this “ruthless transparency” that makes accountability almost brutally clear.

New hires no longer need to ask ten times: Standard procedures are built into the system. Who approves what, who checks content, when is the deadline—all visible at a glance through the task path. Supervisors can also see in real time who’s stuck or which article has been “lying flat” for over eight hours, enabling immediate intervention without blind guesswork. Even better, legal risks have dropped dramatically—unauthorized content simply won’t pass the final gate. The system blocks it automatically, leaving no room to claim “I didn’t mean to.”

Approval is no longer a hidden game, but an open race track. Trust, it turns out, can be built on a single timeline.



The Future Is Here—But Don’t Treat DingTalk as a Miracle Cure

When newsrooms upgrade from chaotic emails to one-click publishing, it feels like going from riding a bicycle to stepping into a spaceship. But don’t assume using DingTalk means entering utopia. No matter how powerful the workflow, it can’t cure human flaws. Take data privacy—working in media in Hong Kong has always been like tap-dancing on a knife’s edge. Now, with every approval trail stored in the cloud, what if a politically sensitive draft gets mislabeled, accidentally shared, or leaked internally? Who’s responsible? DingTalk offers encryption, but its servers are located in mainland China, raising quiet concerns about storage and access to politically sensitive content.

Even more absurd: the smoother the process, the stiffer creativity becomes. One reporter complained: “Changing a headline requires four approvals—harder than applying for a visa!” When every step is standardized, flashes of inspiration get struck down by bureaucratic lightning. Veteran editors miss the spontaneity of approving stories over coffee with a quick verbal nod, now replaced by cold, impersonal to-do reminders. For older colleagues less familiar with tech, figuring out the difference between “adding an approver” and “joint approval” may be more exhausting than writing an entire interview.

Most crucially, no matter how smart DingTalk is, it doesn’t understand the unwritten rules of Hong Kong media: when to speed up and when to slow down; what must never be published, and what should be released “quietly.” Tools can accelerate processes, but without team consensus and clear strategy, even the most sophisticated workflow is just an elaborate way to sink the ship.



We dedicated to serving clients with professional DingTalk solutions. If you'd like to learn more about DingTalk platform applications, feel free to contact our online customer service or email at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. With a skilled development and operations team and extensive market experience, we’re ready to deliver expert DingTalk services and solutions tailored to your needs!

WhatsApp